Sanity is madness put to good use. – George Santayana
I received an email the other day from Erika Stewart, an account executive for an onlinemarketing agency. As the propritor of a nursing blog, I get a lot of letters from people like Erika everyday. They want me to write up a blurb about their clients. I hit delete, delete, delete. Erika’s letter was different. Yes, she’s a publicist, but she wrote a compeling article that deserved a second look.
Erika sent me a short write-up discussing how the Federal Health Care reform will effect nurses and how we practice bedside care. She asked me to read her article and comment on its contents. She wanted my honest opinion about how this reform will affect nurses. This is what Erika wrote:
“The effect of health care reform on nurses set to go into effect in January 2012, the provision for Accountable Care Organizations seeks to improve the outcomes and cost effectiveness of health care in the United States. This is one of the major provisions of the hotly debated healthcare reform law. Nurses will play a critical role in implementing the changes.
All health care organizations in the country must become ACOs in order to receive Medicare reimbursements. The ACO will consist of a team of physicians, hospitals and ancillary care providers responsible for the care of a patient. A set amount will be paid per Medicare recipient, and the ACO must provide services to at least 5,000 Medicare patients over a three-year time period. Payment will be adjusted upward for the care of those with severe or chronic illnesses. Patients with private health insurance will also be served by ACOs.
The ACO system seeks to incorporate the more successful aspects of HMOs without restricting patient choice. The goal of the ACO is to increase quality of outcomes and patient satisfaction while reducing costs. Nurses will be vital members of the team. Dean of Health Sciences and Nursing at Sentinel University, Dr Catherine Garner, DrPH, MSN, MPA, RN, FAAN wrote a series of articles on this topic for Links: HealthCareers.com. She anticipates that the measure will enable nurses to move into managing care, rather than simply providing care. This empowerment will expand the role of the nurse in ensuring appropriate and effective delivery of services.
As the ACOs are established, there will be a high demand for nursing case managers who can help to coordinate services for patients under their care. The case manager will work directly with the patient to educate and provide comprehensive care. This approach should lead to more positive health outcomes and fewer unnecessary hospitalizations. According to the American Nursing Association, nurses will be instrumental in transforming the current “sick care system to a true healthcare system.”
Anticipating an increased demand for RNs, especially those with advanced skills, the healthcare reform law put into place several provisions for supporting the education of nurses. Chief among these is the reauthorization of Title VIII Nursing Workforce Development Programs, the major source of federal funding for nurse education. Money is provided to assist both entry-level nursing students pursuing an associate’s or bachelor’s degree and those seeking advanced training.
The healthcare reform law establishes a new $50 million grant program to prepare nurses to manage private health insurance clinics that can care for underserved populations. It also raises the funding for the National Health Service Corps from $75 million to $300 million. The healthcare reforms being put into place to give all Americans access to health insurance and care rely heavily on well-prepared, dedicated nurses to provide both leadership and management of patient care. These new opportunities carry with them a great deal of responsibility, a welcome change in the field of nursing. The potential of nurses to improve patient care has long been overlooked. Nurses are able to spend the time needed to work closely with patients in planning and executing their health initiatives.With the added incentives of higher paying and more responsible positions, nursing is becoming increasingly attractive to bright, energetic students who are ready to enter this dynamic field. The role of the nurse will be central in the development and maintenance of a successful ACO.”
Erika wrote a very nice article. Unfortunately, there is a huge downside for patients and bedside nurses in the brave new world of healthcare. Hospitals are going to be paid based on patient care outcomes and patient satisfaction. This means that nurses who are already overworked due to a lack of licensed nursing staff are going to be put under more pressure to produce. As a result, many healthcare organizations plan to bring in unlicensed healthcare workers to provide more of the bedside nursing care. Some nurses like Dr Catherine Garner’s, DrPH, MSN, MPA, RN, FAAN applaud this move. I take issue with Dr. Garner’s opinion. I was disturbed by Dr. Garner’s belief that these measures will enable nurses to move into managing care, rather than simply providing care. Bedside nurses are not empowered by this move. Nurses provide superior bedside care, and relegating this responsabilty to unlicensed staff is unsafe. I don’t want untrained caregivers working under my nursing license, nor do I want to be tied down to a desk filling out endless paperwork all day long. I am already an important memeber of the healthcare team and there is nothing wrong with simply providing bedside care.
Well, there you have it. That’s my opinion. Erika, I hope you aren’t too disappointed with my response to your article. Feel free to write to me again. I promise I won’t delete your email.
JA-RN
January 26th, 2012 at 9:03 am
I’m retired now,after being a diploma-grad & working 40+ years in hospitals. I entered nursing to give patient care. The RN’s at the top, with all the letters after their name,have never valued direct patient care-baths & bedpans! Touch a patient? Never!! So, sadly, why are we surprised that they just want more care given by unlicensed caregivers? Will I have a nurse like me if I get sick? Probably not.
Wanderer
January 26th, 2012 at 11:52 am
I and already tell you a little about how health care reform is effecting nurses at the bedside: layoffs. Yup, due to changes in reimbursement related to the overhaul of health care my facility is over $40million in the hole and are resorting to lay-offs to help bridge the gap. Additionally, our ratios are rising resulting in more patients and less staff, but still laboring under the piles of paperwork, regulatory crap while trying to keep our patients alive.
As for advanced practice/more school, yeah, it’s great, I’m looking to get my BSN, but where’s the money coming from? I’m in a one income family, mine, and my work covers $1500 a year for school – if it meets criteria and you pay out of pocket first. That gets all of about 5 credits or so…a year. I can’t afford to go to school, my employer barely pays for it but is on the cusp of requiring it, so I’m stuck.
Sorry to rant, a lot on my mind.
The Mental
January 26th, 2012 at 5:13 pm
Erika’s article has angered me so much that I must not reply now least the blogosphere erupt in flames…I do recommend a relatively new book, Killer Cures. Very interesting ideas about how to fix the healthcare system. It does correctly point out that the Healthcare Reform has NOTHING to do with better healthcare for patients. It is about saving money/cutting costs. That is the bottom line if you dig down far enough. One of the points the author appears to make (I haven’t read the entire book yet, mind you) is that the PATIENT needs to step up and shoulder more responsibility for their own health. IOW, stop doing stupid things or things that you KNOW you aren’t supposed to be doing…and then showing up for someone to fix you–at great cost…so you can do it all over again. Wouldn’t that ease some of the workload you all have? And cut costs? Ok…I’m leaving now to go meditate and think calm thoughts…otherwise I might show up on Mother Jones’ unit.
Cathy Lane RPh
February 4th, 2012 at 1:23 pm
Gave the blog the once-over; gut response– fancy, schmancy ideas.
Focus on practical with what the education for nurses, pharmacists, physicians, physical and respiratory therapists, etc. already provides, and the least amount of bookkeeping.
Having to keep track of other people to ensure the job is done correctly and well is too much work for the overworked professional health care provider.
But, for Pete’s sake, please don’t think for a minute ancillary personnel can claim they provided evaluative, consultative, assessments nor any direct patient care.
Health care is already rampant with too many fingers in the pies of people for which they care not a fig nor invested in the care and outcome of the individual patients.
Disorderlycna
February 11th, 2012 at 3:28 am
Ummm, I don’t think having CNAs take out garbage and dirty linen and stock supplies is a huge threat to quality patient care. Nor is it the end of the world if we help bathe a patient or provide other personal care. And I have yet to meet the RN who didn’t find his or her ability to care for patients harmed by receiving assistance in positioning patients, or serving as a safety companion. And, I have my own license and scope of practice to be concerned about. Just clarifying the CNA’s/PCT’s role in acute care…
Mother Jones, RN
February 11th, 2012 at 7:49 am
I’m talking about letting CNAs pass medications on my license. That’s big. I’m not taking the responsibility for someone else’s errors. And yes, you right about CNAs being an invaluable part of the healthcare team. Nurses can’t run a floor without them.
Disorderlycna
February 11th, 2012 at 10:44 am
Gotcha. Yes, UAP shouldn’t pass meds. However, a licensed CMA (that is the role in OR, anyway) is a different matter. I don’t know to what extent they are employed in acute care, but try running a LTC without one (at least on a hectic day or eve shift, anyway…).
Cathy
November 26th, 2012 at 5:41 pm
Mother J, I could NOT agree more! I have been saying this all along….future hands on ‘nursing’ will not be from RNs. I searched high and low to find information regarding the effect of healthcare reform on the BEDSIDE nurse. All the hoopla is about advanced practice nurses….almost ALL. And bedside RNs everywhere should be concerned…REAL concerned. Our hospital, for years now, has implemented all the criteria to improve patient outcomes and although this, of itself, is a good thing, it has tripled our documentation. We have one required computer screen after another…much of it redundant questions. Patients are ticked off; they are tired of ALL the questions. Yet we are REQUIRED to ask them the same things over and over again (and I am not referring to establishing the correct patient ID, correct patient, correct procedure, etc). I have been an RN for 34 years and I, like most nurses, am a hard worker. But enough is enough. I refuse to refer to my patients as clients and they can take the excessive time needed to document and, well, have an enema with it all. Now, nurses will be responsible for non-reimbursement b/c the patient had complications or was re-admitted. Talk about pressure…if providing outstanding care isn’t enough, NURSES will be the ones thrown under the bus when the hospital is not reimbursed. Mark my words. There has been no effort in retention in our hospital. There are so many nurses in our facility who have 20, 30, 40+ years experience and nothing is done to harvest the years of experience before they jump ship. I am sure administration would be quite happy to say ‘goodbye’ to a seasoned veteran…after all, it’s less $ for them to fork out–just hire a technical worker to take our place…that’ll do! Right? I will be taking my years of experience with me when I leave because I will be doing so shortly. I can not bear to see the profession I’ve dedicated my life to, go up in flames and the patients suffer for it in the long run.